The men that chartered a fishing boat in New Jersey had NO IDEA they were in for a real-life "Jaws" moment when a great white shark came right up to their boat and stole a bag of bait. Captain Jeff Crilly said, "We've fished for sharks a lot and never seen anything like that. We were amazed by how big it was." Coincidentally, the name of the boat is Big Nutz Required II, a 31-foot Bertram sport boat. They estimate the shark was 16-20 feet long and a couple thousand pounds.